Why James Justin Could Strengthen Leeds United’s Backline as Schmidt’s Future Hangs in the Balance

Leeds United’s return to the Premier League under Daniel Farke has been built on stability, structure, and selective recruitment. But as the season kicks off, one position remains in need of reinforcement: full-back. With Isaac Schmidt struggling badly to make his mark, Leicester City’s James Justin is a name that could tick multiple boxes for Leeds.

A Ready-Made Solution

At 27, James Justin has already seen it all — Championship title wins, top-flight survival battles, and even an England cap. Capable of operating on either flank, he brings a level of tactical flexibility Farke values highly. Whether asked to press high, tuck in to protect the centre-backs, or push forward to link play, Justin has shown he can adapt.

His defensive record speaks for itself. At Leicester, he has consistently ranked among the club’s most reliable in tackles, interceptions, and aerial duels. While injuries have interrupted his progress in recent years, he appears to have regained the fitness and focus that once made him one of the most promising full-backs in the country.

Fitting Farke’s Blueprint

Farke’s sides rely on full-backs who understand both phases of the game — aggressive pressing when out of possession, disciplined positioning when holding the ball. Justin’s composure and game intelligence mean he would slot naturally into Leeds’ shape.

Equally important, he brings Premier League know-how at a time when Leeds can’t afford a bedding-in period. That could prove crucial during the early months, when mistakes are often punished harshly.

Leeds United have agreed a deal with Leicester City for James Justin 📝

Sky Sports News understands the total package is worth up to £10m. The initial fee is £8m plus £2m in add-ons 💵 pic.twitter.com/O6wSRDiBnN

— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) August 24, 2025

Schmidt’s Setback

While Justin looks like a safe, dependable option, Isaac Schmidt’s stock at Elland Road has taken a hit. Signed from St. Gallen for a modest fee, the Swiss winger-turned-full-back barely featured in the Championship promotion campaign, managing just a handful of substitute appearances.

This summer was meant to be a fresh start, but pre-season told a different story. In a friendly against Villarreal, Schmidt’s misplaced pass led directly to a goal, prompting visible frustration from Farke and senior teammates. Combined with positional lapses and a lack of composure, it painted the picture of a player short on both confidence and match readiness.

Contrasting Profiles

Where Justin offers reliability and experience, Schmidt remains a gamble on potential. Justin could be trusted from day one to hold his own against Premier League wingers, while Schmidt would still be learning on the job. For a side aiming to avoid a relegation fight, that difference matters.